“I Put A Spell On You” Tenth Anniversary Announces Principal Casting

September 23, 2025
“I Put A Spell On You” Tenth Anniversary Announces Principal Casting

Creator and executive producer Jay Armstrong Johnson and producers Andy Jones, Joe Hornberger, and Shannon Molly Flynn have announced the cast for the tenth anniversary celebration of “I Put a Spell on You,” a fundraiser for the Ali Forney Center on Mon Oct 20th at 8:00 PM at Webster Hall (125 E 11th St). Joining the witchery will be Robyn Hurder, Krysta Rodriguez, Sean McManus, Taylor Iman Jones, Jake Pedersen, Julia Mattison, Karma Jenkins, Tim Murray, and more. 
Jay Armstrong Johnson, Allison Godleski and Amanda Williams Ware return to the show as the Sanderson sisters from renowned Halloween classic, “Hocus Pocus.”  The evening’s coven will also include Natalie Hinds as Dani Dennison, Maddox Martin as Max Dennison, and Kathryn Priest as Allison, with additional casting to be announced. The evening will be directed by Heath Saunders and Mack Brown. Joining the creative team is DW (Creative Director), Kyle Krueger (Director of Hair and Makeup), Andrew Garvis (Lighting Design), Connor Wang and Jaechelle Johnson (Sound Design), Sean Gorski of Hudson Theatrical (Technical Supervisor), Jackson Teeley (Music Supervisor), Michael Anthony Sylvester (Supervising Choreographer), Will Van Dyke (Music Consultant), Brian Pacelli (Video Supervision), and Andy Diaz (Props Supervision). Caroline Pastore will serve as the Production Stage Manager and Megan Saunders will serve as Production Manager. Press Contact: DKC/O&M (212/695-7400)...